Opponent
|
First Game
|
Record vs.
|
| Alabama A&M |
2024 |
0-1 |
| Alderson Broaddus University |
2015 |
1-1 |
| Alfred Holbrook |
1937 |
3-0 |
| Alma |
1976 |
1-0 |
| Anderson |
1965 |
2-0 |
| Ashland |
1980 |
0-8 |
| Ave Maria |
2021 |
1-0 |
| Austin Peay |
1949 |
0-1 |
| Azusa Pacific |
1999 |
1-0 |
| Bacone |
2005 |
1-1 |
| Baker University |
2017 |
1-0 |
| Belhaven |
1998 |
11-0 |
| Benedictine |
2011 |
1-0 |
| Berea |
1904 |
2-1-1 |
| Bethel (TN) |
1995 |
14-4 |
| Bluefield College (VA) |
2012 |
8-0 |
| Bluffton |
1970 |
3-0 |
| Butler |
1910 |
2-9 |
| Camp Buell |
1918 |
1-0 |
| Camp Taylor |
1917 |
0-1 |
| Campbellsville |
1988 |
30-5 |
| Carlisle High School |
1905 |
0-1 |
| Carroll College |
2000 |
2-3 |
| Carson-Newman |
1927 |
7-16-2 |
| Cedarville |
1946 |
3-0-2 |
| Central Kentucky |
1898 |
0-2 |
| Central Univ. |
1914 |
1-0 |
| Centre |
1893 |
9-31-1 |
| Cincinnati |
1894 |
3-8 |
| Cin. Ath. Club |
1901 |
0-1 |
| Cincinnati Celts |
1914 |
1-0 |
| Cincinnati Christian University |
2016 |
3-0 |
| Cincinnati Medics |
1905 |
0-1 |
| Cin. Woodard High |
1896 |
1-0 |
| Concord |
1949 |
2-1 |
| Concordia University (MI) |
2021 (S) |
0-1 |
| Covington H.S |
1911 |
1-0 |
| Cumberlands (KY) |
1921 |
33-8 |
| Cumberland (TN) |
1995 |
19-4 |
| Cynthiana |
1906 |
2-0 |
| Davidson |
1982 |
0-1 |
| Dayton |
1920 |
0-10 |
| Defiance |
1964 |
2-1 |
| DePauw |
1908 |
2-4 |
| Earlham |
1916 |
4-0 |
| East Tennessee |
1946 |
0-1 |
| Eastern Kentucky |
1925 |
7-3-1 |
| Eastern Michigan |
1930 |
0-1 |
| Emory & Henry |
1960 |
8-9 |
| Eureka (IL) |
1991 |
1-0 |
| Evansville |
1939 |
11-4 |
| Faulkner (AL) |
2012 |
7-2 |
| Findlay (OH) |
1941 |
6-1 |
| Frankfort |
1893 |
2-0 |
| Franklin |
1917 |
18-19 |
| Ft. Campbell |
1951 |
0-1 |
| Ft. Knox |
1951 |
0-3 |
| Gardner Webb |
1970 |
3-4 |
| Geneva (PN) |
2005 |
1-0 |
| Georgetown Ath. Club |
1912 |
1-0 |
| Glenville State |
1979 |
1-1 |
| Hanover |
1916 |
20-5-1 |
| Heidelberg |
1976 |
2-0 |
| Hillsdale |
1979 |
1-0 |
| Hope |
1971 |
0-1 |
| Iowa Wesleyan |
1998 |
2-0 |
| Indiana (B) |
1929 |
1-0 |
| Indiana Central |
1978 |
2-6 |
| Indianapolis |
1986 |
1-1 |
| Keiser University |
2018 |
1-1 |
| Kentucky Christian |
2008 |
12-1 |
| Kentucky Military |
1900 |
1-2 |
| Kentucky State |
1918 |
2-4 |
| Kentucky Wesleyan |
1900 |
22-4 |
| Knoxville |
1992 |
1-0 |
| Lambuth |
1990 |
13-6 |
| Lane |
1993 |
1-0 |
| Lenoir-Rhyne |
1960 |
0-1 |
| Lexington Ath. Club |
1914 |
0-1 |
| Lexington H.S |
1910 |
5-1 |
| Liberty Baptist |
1979 |
0-1 |
| Lindenwood |
1993 |
2-1 |
| Lindenwood-Belleville |
2014 |
1-0 |
| Lindsey Wilson |
2010 |
5-9 |
| Louisville |
1908 |
9-7 |
| Louisville Ath Club |
1894 |
0-1 |
| Louisville Male H.S |
1906 |
2-2 |
| Louisville YMCA |
1895 |
0-3 |
| Malone |
1998 |
2-0 |
| Manchester |
1940 |
0-0-1 |
| Marian University |
2014 |
0-1 |
| Marietta |
1915 |
4-2 |
| Mars Hill |
1965 |
3-8 |
| Marshall |
1904 |
2-10 |
| Maryville |
1919 |
14-11-1 |
| McKendree College |
2002 |
1-3 |
| Memphis Navy |
1962 |
2-0 |
| Miami (OH) |
1906 |
0-8-1 |
| Michigan State |
1928 |
0-1 |
| Mid-America Nazarene |
2004 |
1-1 |
| Millersburg |
1902 |
1-0 |
| Milligan |
1941 |
1-0 |
| Millsaps |
1961 |
9-4 |
| Mississippi College |
1997 |
1-1 |
| Missouri-Rolla |
1994 |
0-1 |
| Morehead State |
1936 |
1-7-1 |
| Morris Harvey |
1922 |
1-3-1 |
| Mount St. Joseph |
1990 |
4-0 |
| Mount St. Joseph (IN) |
1999 |
1-1 |
| Murray State |
1936 |
0-1 |
| Muskingum |
1939 |
0-2 |
| N.W.Oklahoma St. |
1999 |
1-1 |
| North Greenville |
1995 |
7-0 |
| North Park |
1969 |
1-0 |
| Northwood |
1970 |
3-6-1 |
| Oberlin |
1973 |
1-0 |
| Ohio |
1932 |
0-2 |
| Ohio Dominican College |
2013 |
0-1 |
| Ohio Northern |
1972 |
2-3 |
| Olivet Nazarene |
1992 |
2-0 |
| Ottawa |
2011 |
1-0 |
| Otterbein |
1987 |
1-0 |
| Pacific Lutheran (WA) |
1991 |
1-0 |
| Paris Ath. Club |
1904 |
1-0 |
| Peru State (NB) |
1991 |
1-0 |
| Pikeville |
2001 |
20-2 |
| Point University |
2017 |
1-0 |
| Principia |
1964 |
2-0 |
| Reinhardt University |
2015 |
1-5 |
| Rio Grande |
1939 |
1-0 |
| Rose Hulman |
1926 |
2-0-1 |
| Saint Joseph (IN) |
2001 |
1-0 |
| Salem |
1950 |
1-1 |
| Salisbury |
1978 |
1-0 |
| Sanford |
1909 |
0-5 |
| Sewanee |
1920 |
0-1 |
| Shepherd |
1991 |
0-1 |
| Shorter |
2005 |
3-1 |
| Southeastern University |
2019 |
0-1 |
| Southwestern Tenn. |
1928 |
1-2 |
| St. Ambrose Univ. |
2002 |
1-0 |
| St. Andrews Univerity |
2018 |
2-0 |
| St. Francis (IL) |
1999 |
2-0 |
| St. Francis (IN) |
1999 |
4-3 |
| St. Francis St. |
2000 |
1-0 |
| St. Joseph's (IN) |
1969 |
4-5 |
| St. Mary's |
1915 |
3-0 |
| St. Thomas (FL) |
2024 |
1-0 |
| St. Xavier (IL) |
2006 |
0-1 |
| Steubenville College |
1948 |
1-0 |
| Taylor |
1952 |
3-3 |
| Tennessee |
1900 |
0-3 |
| Tennessee-Martin |
1958 |
2-0 |
| Tennessee Tech |
1946 |
1-3 |
| Tennessee Wesleyan |
1955 |
3-2 |
| Thomas More (KY) |
2019 |
4-0 |
| Tiffin |
1987 |
2-0 |
| Toledo |
1937 |
0-1 |
| Transylvania |
1893 |
19-18 |
| Trinity Intl. Univ |
2004 |
1-0 |
| Tri-State |
1997 |
1-2 |
| Tusculum |
1991 |
3-2 |
| U of Kentucky |
1893 |
4-21 |
| U of Sioux Falls |
2001 |
1-0 |
| UVA-Wise |
2000 |
10-3 |
| Union (TN) |
1925 |
6-4 |
| Union College (KY) |
1930 |
31-5-3 |
| Urbana |
1990 |
3-0 |
| UT-Chattanooga |
1913 |
3-5 |
| Valparaiso |
1980 |
3-1 |
| Vanderbilt |
1904 |
0-2 |
| Versailles |
1904 |
1-0 |
| Versailles Ath. Club |
1909 |
1-0 |
| Wabash |
1910 |
1-6-1 |
| Warner University |
2018 |
1-0 |
| Webber International |
2009 |
2-1 |
| West Liberty |
1963 |
0-2 |
| West Virginia State |
1975 |
3-0 |
| West Virginia Tech |
1948 |
17-4-1 |
| West Virginia Wesleyan |
1963 |
0-2 |
| Western Kentucky |
1927 |
2-7 |
| Westminster (PA) |
1987 |
0-7 |
| Wheaton |
1967 |
1-2 |
| Wilmington |
1915 |
5-2 |
| Winchester |
1907 |
1-0 |
| Wittenberg |
1923 |
1-6 |
| Wofford |
1928 |
0-3 |
| Xavier |
1903 |
3-9 |