NAIA All Americans

Baseball

1987 - Tim Redman - First Team
2006 - Adam Burks - Honorable Mention
2012 - Chad Ritchie - Second Team
2012 - Tyler Arthur - Second Team
2014 - Martin Lemus - First Team
2014 - Tyler Arthur - Honorable Mention
2018 - Shawn Dubin - First Team
2019 - Chris Gilbody - Honorable Mention

Cheerleading (modern era)

2019 - Madi Webster - First Team

Softball

2016 - Chaselyn Allgeier - Honorable Mention
2018 - Kara Howard - Honorable Mention

Women's Track and Field (modern era)

2016 - Tayler Godar (800-meter run)
2019 - Emma Bianchi (High Jump)

Men's Basketball

1959 - Charles Grote - First Team
1959 - Raymond Withrow - Third Team
1962 - Dick Vories - Second Team
1962 - Joe Farris - Third Team
1963 - Cecil Tuttle - First Team
1964 - Cecil Tuttle - First Team
1964 - Dick Vories - Second Team
1969 - Kenny Davis - Second Team
1970 - Kenny Davis - First Team
1971 - Kenny Davis - First Team
1974 - Andy Williams - Second Team
1975 - Andy Williams - First Team
1991 - Russell Chadwell - Second Team
1992 - Allen McCowan - First Team
1993 - Mark Tandy - First Team
1993 - Russell Chadwell - Second Team
1994 - Mark Tandy - First Team
1994 - Jason Woodard - Second Team
1995 - Jason Woodard - First Team
1996 - Jermaine Brown - First Team
1998 - Will Carlton
1999 - Barry Bowman - First Team
1999 - Will Carlton - First Team
2000 - Will Carlton - First Team
2000 - Todd Cox - Honorable Mention
2002 - Antwan Jones - Second Team
2003 - Quintin Bailey - Second Team
2004 - George Baker - First Team
2004 - Marshall Williams - Third Team
2005 - Brian Silverhorn - Honorable Mention
2006 - Brian Silverhorn - Second Team
2006 - Mark Surgalski - Honorable Mention
2007 - Brian Silverhorn - First Team
2008 - Gordon "Gus" Chase - First Team
2008 - Demetrius Guions - Honorable Mention
2009 - Demetrius Guions - Second Team
2009 - Vic Moses - Honorable Mention
2010 - Hollis Giles - Second Team
2010 - Vic Moses - Honorable Mention
2012 - Maurice Pearson - Third Team
2013 - Vic Moses - First Team
2014 - Monty Wilson - First Team
2015 - Deondre McWhorter - Second Team
2015 - Noah Cottrill - Third Team
2016 - Deondre McWhorter - First Team
2016 - Noah Cottrill - First Team
2016 - Tony Kimbro - Honorable Mention
2017 - Quan Poindexter - Honorable Mention
2017 - Troy Steward - Honorable Mention
2018 - Shadell Millinghaus - First Team
2018 - Quan Poindexter - Honorable Mention
2018 - Troy Steward - Honorable Mention
2019 - Eljay Cowherd - Third Team
2019 - Chris Coffey - Honorable Mention
2019 - Troy Steward - Honorable Mention
2020 - Chris Coffey - First Team
2020 - Eljay Cowherd - Third Team
2020 - Jacob Conway - Honorable Mention
2021 - Kyran Jones - Honorable Mention

Women's Basketball

1992 - Susan VanArsdale - Second Team
1993 - Tammy Kindrick - Second Team
1994 - Tammy Kindrick - Second Team
2002 - Andi Johnson - Second Team
2003 - Andi Johnson - Third Team
2004 - Rachel Vincent - Third Team
2005 - Candas Smith - Honorable Mention
2005 - Neeley Thomas - Second Team
2006 - Kim Ingle - Third Team
2008 - Jayme Gilbert - Honorable Mention
2009 - Jayme Gilbert - Honorable Mention
2010 - Kourtney Tyra - Honorable Mention
2012 - Andrea Howard - Third Team
2013 - Kourtney Tyra - Second Team
2014 - Andrea Howard - First Team
2014 - Kourtney Tyra - Second Team
2015 - Devanny King - Third Team
2015 - Jessica Foster - Honorable Mention
2016 - Jessica Foster - Honorable Mention
2017 - Emilie Ziese - Honorable Mention

Football

1958 - Duke Owens - Second Team
1959 - Neal McFarren - Third Team
1959 - Larry Phillips - Honorable Mention
1959 - Jack Massie - Honorable Mention
1963 - Charlie Gregory - Honorable Mention
1963 - Kyle Ramey - Honorable Mention
1965 - Tom Seals - First Team
1966 - Tom Seals - First Team
1968 - Bob Olson - Hononable Mention
1969 - Bob Olson - Honorable Mention
1970 - Tom Fink - Honorable Mention
1970 - Grant Robinson - Honorable Mention
1974 - Charles Pierson - Second Team
1976 - Rubin McIntyre - First Team
1976 - Kim Graham - Honorable Mention
1978 - John Martinelli - First Team
1983 - Mike Ward - Second Team
1984 - Kent Garrett - Second Team
1984 - Eric Metzger - Honorable Mention
1985 - Rob McCrary
1986 - Forty Jackson - Second Team
1987 - Chris Reed - First Team
1987 - Forty Jackson - Second Team
1988 - Chris Reed - First Team
1988 - Dan Shearer - Second Team
1988 - Mitch Winburn - Second Team
1989 - Mitch Winburn - Second Team
1989 - Steve Blankenbaker - Second Team
1989 - Tim Ritzie - Honorable Mention
1990 - Brian McKenzie
1990 - Brett Kelly
1990 - Tim Ritzie
1991 - Chris Hogan - First Team
1991 - Gary Miller - Second Team
1991 - Dane Damron - Second Team
1992 - Chris Hogan - First Team
1992 - Dane Damron - First Team
1992 - Chris Grego - Honorable Mention
1992 - Steve Hill - Honorable Mention
1992 - Allen McCowan - Honorable Mention
1992 - Brad Sherman - Honorable Mention
1993 - Steve Hill
1995 - Chad McCollam - Second Team
1999 - Shane Pearson - First Team
1999 - Walt DeLong - First Team
1999 - Eddie Eviston - First Team
1999 - Frank Parks - First Team
2000 - Walt DeLong - First Team
2000 - Eddie Eviston - First Team
2000 - Tony Steele - First Team
2000 - Shane Pearson - First Team
2000 - Kevin Davis - Second Team
2001 - Walt DeLong - First Team
2001 - Eddie Eviston - First Team
2002 - Shan Housekeeper - First Team
2002 - Reese Hicks - Second Team
2002 - Sean Cronin - Second Team
2003 - John Michael Sullivan - First Team
2003 - Seth Faulkner - Second Team
2004 - John Michael Sullivan - First Team
2004 - Chris Wergers - Second Team
2004 - Jeff Smith - Second Team
2004 - Michael Hudson - Second Team
2004 - Clay Martin - Honorable Mention
2005 - Kenya Williams - First Team
2005 - Gabe Guthrie - Second Team
2005 - Mike Crum - Honorable Mention
2005 - David Penland - Honorable Mention
2006 - Clay Hamblen - First Team
2007 - Clay Hamblen - First Team
2010 - Kyle Anderson - First Team
2011 - Zach Goebel - First Team
2012 - Chris Gohman - First Team
2013 - Brock Messina - First Team
2014 - Nick Seither - Second Team
2017 - Cameron Oshodi - Second Team
2019 - Starr Thompson - First Team
2019 - Landon Corolla - Honorable Mention
2019 - JJ Ogbogu - Honorable Mention
2021 (S) - DJ White - First Team
2021 (S) - Marcus Omosule - Second Team
2022 - DJ White - First Team

Women's Lacrosse

2016 - Bea Cameron - First Team
2016 - Avery Blackmon - First Team
2016 - Rachel Kidwell - First Team
2016 - Laura Cuseo - Second Team
2016 - Merrisa Heraldson - Second Team
2016 - Katharine Leighty - Second Team
2017 - Avery Blackmon - First Team
2017 - Merrisa Heraldson - First Team
2017 - Sam Dearing - Second Team
2017 - Rachel Kidwell - Second Team
2018 - Avery Blackmon - First Team
2018 - Katherine Leighty - Second Team
2019 - Avery Blackmon - First Team
2019 - Katherine Leighty - First Team
2020 - NOT AWARD (COVID)
2021 - Tyelar Rohman - First Team

Women's Soccer

2002 - Elizabeth "Lizzie" Brown - Honorable Mention
2004 - Meghan Scott - Third Team
2004 - Leah Crews- Honorable Mention
2004 - Brittany Hunt - Honorable Mention
2005 - Meghan Scott - Honorable Mention
2017 - Bethany Massey - Honorable Mention
2017 - Megan Martin - Honorable Mention

Men's Tennis

2008 - Matias Carcamo - Second Team
2008 - Andres Escalante - Honorable Mention
2017 - Ryo Takeda - Honorable Mention

Women's Tennis

2007 - Emily Kerrick - Honorable Mention
2007 - Sarah Yost - Honorable Mention
2008 - Adrienne Bartlett - Honorable Mention
2008 - Emily Kerrick - Honorable Mention
2008 - Sarah Yost - Honorable Mention
2009 - Adrienne Bartlett - Honorable Mention
2009 - Emily Kerrick - Honorable Mention
2009 - Sarah Yost - Honorable Mention
2017 - Shae Henry - Second Team
2019 - Lauren Fazenbaker - Honorable Mention

Volleyball

1988 - Nancy Hulsmeyer - Honorable Mention
1989 - Nancy Hulsmeyer - Second Team
1990 - Chris Schimmoeller - Third Team
1990 - Jennifer Nuss - Honorable Mention
1991 - Nancy Hulsmeyer - Honoroable Mention
1991 - Jennifer Nuss - Honorable Mention
1992 - Monica Beam - Honorable Mention
1992 - Nancy Hulsmeyer Gould - First Team
1993 - Monica Beam - Honorable Mention
1993 - Erin Monnier - Honorable Mention
1994 - Erin Monnier - Second Team
1995 - Erin Monnier - Honorable Mention
1996 - Jalana Daeger - Honorable Mention
1998 - Lindsey Thieneman - Honorable Mention
1999 - Susan Clements - Third Team
1999 - Lindsey Thieneman - Second Team
2000 - Susan Clements - First Team
2000 - Lindsey Thieneman - Honorable Mention
2000 - Beth Vieth - Honorable Mention
2001 - Susan Clements - First Team
2001 - Lindsey Thieneman - Honorable Mention
2001 - Beth Vieth - Honorable Mention
2003 - Kara Hellmann - Honorable Mention
2003 - Jessica Leonard - Honorable Mention
2004 - Kara Hellmann - Second Team
2004 - Jessica Leonard - Third Team
2005 - Kara Hellmann - Second Team
2006 - Amy Schiller - Third Team
2007 - Erica Janszen - Honorable Mention
2008 - Jenna Gronotte - Honorable Mention
2008 - Erica Janszen - Third Team
2009 - Erica Janszen - Third Team
2009 - Amy Barmore - Honorable Mention
2010 - Kyla Welch - Honorable Mention
2012 - Rachel Eubanks - Third Team
2012 - Caraline Maher - Honorable Mention
2013 - Caraline Maher - Second Team
2013 - Allyson Wilbourn - Honorable Mention
2014 - Caraline Maher - Third Team
2014 - Allyson Wilbourn - Third Team
2015 - Jenny Howell - Third Team
2015 - Corri Muha - Honorable Mention
2016 - Jenny Howell - Second Team
2016 - Sarah Bell - Honorable Mention
2016 - Ashlee Howe - Honorable Mention
2017 - Jenny Howell - Honorable Mention
2017 - Caroline Ricks - Honorable Mention
2021 (S) - Hunter Keller - Honorable Mention